← BACK TO FEED

What Is ETF Overlap? How to Check It and How Much Is Too Much

ETF overlap measures how much of two funds' money sits in the same stocks. See the weighted-overlap formula, dated figures for eight popular pairs, what each overlap range means and how to check your own portfolio.

PortLens Team

ETF overlap is the percentage of two funds' portfolios that is invested in the same underlying stocks. It matters because owning several overlapping funds concentrates your portfolio invisibly: your brokerage statement shows three or four tidy ticker symbols, while underneath, the same handful of mega-cap stocks may dominate all of them.

The pair comparisons are computed from SEC N-PORT filings dated between May 31 and July 31, 2026; where a pair's two funds filed on different dates, the figure is stated as of the older filing. Each linked pair page shows its current result and source dates. The whole-portfolio example uses a separately dated September 8, 2026 calculation, with the methodology and holdings dates beside it.

How is ETF overlap measured?

The standard measure is overlap by weight: for every stock held by both funds, take the smaller of its two portfolio weights, then add those minimums up. Summed across every shared holding, this tells you what fraction of your money is effectively invested identically in both funds.

Take SPY and VOO, two funds tracking the S&P 500. NVIDIA is 7.52% of SPY and 7.51% of VOO, so it contributes 7.51 points of overlap. Apple is 6.59% and 6.59%, contributing 6.59. Repeat across all 500 stocks the two funds share and the total comes to 99.5%. Put $10,000 into each and roughly $9,950 of the second position is invested identically to the first.

Counting shared names instead overstates how different two funds are, and sometimes gets the answer backwards. VB and VTI share 1,308 holdings, yet they overlap by just 11.9% of weight: VTI's money sits in mega-caps, and the small-cap names the two funds share are a rounding error inside it. VTV and VUG share only 21 names and overlap by 3.7%. Weight determines how a pair behaves; the name count doesn't.

Pair Overlap by weight Shared stocks What it means
SPY vs VOO 99.5% 500 Same index; separate funds with heavily shared holdings
VOO vs VTI 88.1% 502 Total market ≈ S&P 500 plus a small-cap sliver
VGT vs XLK 80.6% 73 Two tech sector funds, heavily redundant
VOO vs VUG 57.5% 121 Growth fund holds the biggest names at heavier weights
VOO vs VYM 34.4% 256 Genuine common ground, different center of gravity
VB vs VTI 11.9% 1,308 Many shared names, almost no shared weight
VTV vs VUG 3.7% 21 Value and growth; little shared company weight
VTI vs VXUS 0.2% 19 US and ex-US: near-disjoint by construction

Every pair page shows the top shared holdings with each fund's exact weights, the holdings date its figure is anchored to, and links to both funds' SEC filings. Browse the curated pairs or enter two tickers in the ETF overlap checker.

Why does ETF overlap matter at the portfolio level?

A single overlapping pair may give you little beyond another line item to track. The larger issue shows up across the whole portfolio, because overlap compounds in a way pairwise checks do not reveal: each fund can look like a reasonable addition to every other fund while all of them load the same names.

Take a fictional allocation of 45% VOO, 25% VUG, 20% VGT and 10% Apple. The direct Apple line says 10%. Once you include its positions inside all three funds, Apple accounts for 18.8% of the portfolio.

PortLens computed this example on September 8, 2026 using SEC N-PORT holdings dated June 30, 2026 for VOO and VUG, and May 31, 2026 for VGT. Those are dated snapshots and never live holdings. The calculation follows our methodology.

Route to Apple Portfolio allocation Apple's weight inside the fund Contribution to portfolio
VOO 45% 6.590% 2.965%
VUG 25% 11.669% 2.917%
VGT 20% 14.568% 2.914%
Direct Apple holding 10% N/A 10.000%
Combined 18.796%, or 18.8% rounded

The full-source calculation returns 100% look-through coverage for this sample: every fund resolves. That does not certify every underlying asset's weight or guarantee the same coverage for other portfolios. Published lists can retain an unattributed tail, and share classes can appear separately. The result is a saved snapshot of a fictional allocation, never a suggested portfolio.

Fictional September 8, 2026 example: 10% held directly in Apple becomes 18.8% with VOO, VUG and VGT included. Two dotted bars on one scale: 10.00% on the statement, then 18.80% once the funds add 2.97 points via VOO, 2.92 via VUG and 2.91 via VGT. Fund holdings are dated June 30 and May 31, 2026.
The same Apple exposure, shown before and after adding the three fund contributions. The table above supplies each route and its weight.

You can download the calculation inputs as CSV and open the chart as SVG. The CSV uses fractions throughout: multiply each portfolio weight by Apple's weight within that position, sum the four contributions, then multiply by 100. It preserves the unrounded contributions from the saved example; it is not a download of the funds' full holdings files.

To cite this example: PortLens Team, “What Is ETF Overlap?”, fictional portfolio calculation prepared September 8, 2026, published by Finsight Labs Ltd at PortLens.io. Link to this calculation and its source dates. The conclusion applies to this allocation and these dated holdings, not to portfolios in general.

Inputs and contributions in the table are rounded separately; the calculation uses unrounded weights. The funds add about 8.8 percentage points to the direct Apple position. A pairwise overlap percentage cannot tell you that total because it does not know your allocation or your direct stocks.

You can explore the clickable example on the homepage, or check the underlying company exposure in your own portfolio. The free scan takes up to 5 holdings without an account and flags low coverage.

Is ETF overlap bad, and how much is too much?

ETF overlap is not bad in itself: it measures how much of one fund repeats the other, and whether that is too much depends on the size of the figure and on what you hold the second fund for.

What the number describes changes with scale. Above roughly 70%, the two funds largely hold the same weights: most of the money in one is already in the other. SPY and VOO at 99.5% hold effectively the same basket. VGT and XLK at 80.6% share the majority of their weight in the same technology names. Between roughly 40% and 70%, a meaningful share is invested identically, but each fund still carries weight the other does not. VOO and VUG at 57.5% share a large core while the growth fund holds the same largest companies at roughly 1.7 to 1.8 times VOO's weights (NVIDIA, Apple and Microsoft; Amazon is about 1.2 times). Between roughly 15% and 40%, the funds share real common ground while each brings exposure the other lacks. VOO and VYM at 34.4% hold many of the same companies at different centers of gravity. Below roughly 15%, little of the money in one fund is invested identically in the other, even when the names repeat. VB and VTI share 1,308 names yet overlap by just 11.9%.

Those ranges are the Near identical, Heavy, Moderate and Low levels PortLens shows on its pair pages. They are descriptive interface choices, not academically established targets or instructions to trade. No standard threshold exists; the investigation of differing overlap percentages shows why applying a cutoff before identifying the measure produces contradictory answers.

Two things change the reading. Position sizes: a 90% overlap between two positions that are each 1% of your portfolio barely registers, while the same overlap between your two largest positions can dominate it. And intent: overlap matters most when you were counting on the second fund for diversification it does not add. When the unshared slice is the reason you hold it, the shared weight is a trade-off you chose.

What should I do about funds that overlap a lot?

The overlap figure tells you how much of two funds' money sits in the same companies, at the same size. What to do about it depends on what you meant each fund to contribute. Three questions can help you read your own result:

  • What did you buy the second fund to do? The overlap figure measures how much of its weight repeats the first fund. Whether that repetition is a problem depends on the job, and only you know what the job was.
  • How much of the second fund is not already in the first? A 57.5% overlap leaves 42.5% of each fund's weight unmatched, and part of that can be extra weight in companies both funds hold. What that 42.5% holds, and whether the rest of your portfolio already covers it, tells you what the pairing adds.
  • Was the duplication chosen, or did it accumulate? Positions bought years apart, under different rules or in different accounts, can duplicate each other without anyone choosing it. Knowing which changes what the overlap figure means.

Those are tests for your own portfolio, and they have no universal answer. The overlap number describes how a portfolio is built; it does not decide what to change. All investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal, and past performance does not guarantee future results.

Is ETF overlap the same as correlation?

No, though the two are easy to conflate. Overlap is a holdings measure: how much of the same stock do these two funds own? Correlation is a behavior measure: do their returns move together?

The relationship runs one way only. High overlap usually suggests high correlation, but the holdings snapshot here cannot by itself establish a historical or future return relationship; correlation must be estimated from returns over a stated time window. But low overlap implies nothing at all about correlation. VTI and VXUS overlap by 0.2%, essentially disjoint baskets of US and international companies, and they are still both equity funds exposed to the same global risk appetite. In a broad risk-off move, "different holdings" is not much protection.

Overlap answers am I buying the same companies twice? Correlation answers have these moved together over the window you measure? You need both, and they fail differently: a portfolio can pass the overlap check and still be one bet, which is the subject of diversification beyond sector splits and factor exposure.

What doesn't overlap by weight tell you?

The measure is precise about a narrow question, and knowing its edges keeps you from over-reading it.

  • It is bounded by data coverage. Overlap can only count holdings that are published. The VTI vs VXUS comparison covers 100% of VTI's weight and 98% of VXUS's, so the true figure could be slightly higher. Computed pair pages link both funds' SEC filings, so the holdings behind each figure can be checked.
  • Even twin funds don't compute at exactly 100%. SPY and VOO, both filed as of June 30, 2026, reach 99.5%: the two filings list 503 and 504 constituents and share 500, their published weights differ in the second decimal, and the smaller weight is the one that counts. Different holdings dates can also change the result, which is why every pair page anchors its figure to the older of the two dates and states it.
  • Share classes count as separate names. Alphabet appears twice in the SPY/VOO table, as GOOGL and GOOG. Overlap is computed per ticker, so one company can look like two positions.
  • It is silent about your position sizes. A pair page knows nothing about how much of each fund you own, and that is what converts a percentage into a real exposure.
  • It is pairwise. Three-way stacking hides between the pairs, as the worked example above shows.

It is also a snapshot. Index reconstitutions and drift move these numbers, so read each example's source dates above.

How do I check ETF overlap in my own portfolio?

For a single pair, use an overlap checker that publishes the underlying numbers (shared holdings, each fund's weights and the source filings) rather than a bare percentage. When PortLens publishes a computed figure, the overlap page shows all of this from SEC N-PORT constituent lists, with the method documented in our methodology.

For a whole portfolio, pairwise checks aren't enough, because stacking hides between the pairs. A portfolio-level look-through explodes every fund into its constituents and sums your exposure to each underlying company across every position. That produces the numbers that actually describe your concentration:

  • your effective number of holdings: a top-heavy portfolio of twelve positions can behave like four;
  • the share of your money in your ten largest underlying companies;
  • which underlying companies appear in more than one of your holdings, how many funds each appears in, and whether you also hold it directly;
  • how much of the portfolio could be looked through at all, so you know what the figures rest on.

The free scan computes these measures for the holdings you enter and flags low coverage beside the result.

Key takeaways

  • Overlap by weight adds the smaller weight of each shared holding. Counting names answers a different question.
  • Position sizes turn pair overlap into portfolio exposure; no universal percentage decides whether your allocation is suitable.
  • The dated four-position example turns 10% held directly in Apple into 18.8% combined exposure after looking through the three funds.
  • Low overlap does not mean low correlation. Funds can hold different companies and still move together.
  • Read the source dates and coverage with every figure. A resolved fund can still have an unattributed tail in its published list.

This article is for information and education only and is not investment advice. Analytics referenced are computed as described in our methodology; see our disclosures.